Content Licensing: The Key to Preserving Freedom and Meritocracy on the Internet
Published on 2024-10-01 by Chomes
The internet, as we know it, is at a turning point. What began as a chaotic but fundamentally open ecosystem has been increasingly shaped by commercialization. Every tweet, meme, or blog post created by an individual user becomes part of the broader content ecosystem, often utilized in ways that prioritize corporate interests.
This commercialization goes beyond ads. It affects control over content, shifting user-generated material into a predominantly corporate playground where the value of individual contributions can be overshadowed. This article explores a potential solution to regain control over content ownership: content licensing.
The Problem: Commercial Exploitation of User Content
Content posted online—whether a clever phrase, an insightful post, or a photo—is often used by platform companies for their own benefit, without direct compensation to the creator. This practice devalues individual contributions and opens the door for exploitation by bots and automated actors. In 2023, bots accounted for a staggering 49.6% of all internet traffic, with malicious bots making up 32% of that[1]. These bots are primarily responsible for scraping user-generated content, often for commercial purposes, leaving creators without control over how their work is used or monetized.
Key Challenges in the Current Internet Landscape:
- Automated Content Scraping: Bots frequently copy user-generated content without consent, often for profit or to spread misinformation. With bot scraping increasing by 432% in recent years, this unauthorized use not only disregards the creator's rights but also erodes trust in online spaces.
Analysis shows that scraping is now one of the top five most popular attacks for all industries and increased 432% in Q2 over Q1 2023, making scraping the fastest-growing attack type
- 2023 Imperva Bad Bot Report [1]- Ad Monetization: Platforms make significant revenue from advertisements that surround user-generated content, yet the content, users, and creators are secondary to the real customer, advertisers. This dynamic leads platforms to focus on maximizing attention on ad impressions rather than the intrinsic value of the content itself.
To help our customers continue to reach their audience in creative ways and build their brands through video, we introduced LinkedIn CTV ads...
- Microsoft Earnings Release FY24 Q4 [2]Our CTV solution is powered by data from our LinkedIn Economic Graph and AI algorithms to empower our customers ... through streaming television content. From our initial tests, customers have reported seeing significant improvement in brand lift, as well as lower funnel outcomes for audiences exposed to CTV campaigns. LinkedIn VP of Engineering, Sanjay Dubey, via LinkedIn. [3]
- Erosion of Trust: The widespread copying and manipulation of content by bots have contributed to a decline in trust. As bots become more sophisticated—often using AI to mimic human behavior—users face increasing difficulty distinguishing authentic content from automated or scraped material.
Russian bot showings its true form
The Consequences of Losing Authentic Human Content
As more content is generated by bots or optimized solely for ad revenue, we risk an internet devoid of authentic human creativity. Some researchers refer to this scenario as the "Dead Internet" hypothesis, where much of the online activity is driven by automated actors rather than real human engagement. This trend could undermine the internet's original meritocratic ideals, where valuable ideas gained prominence based on their quality.
The Solution: Licensing Your Content
One potential solution is content licensing. By adopting licenses such as CC-NC-SA, creators can signal that their content is not for commercial use. This approach supports ethical content sharing and can help differentiate between authentic, non-commercial contributions and content created for profit.
Benefits of Licensing Your Content:
- Discourages Unauthorized Use: While bots may still ignore licensing, clearly labeled content can help ethical users identify and respect non-commercial works. This distinction can foster a community of creators who prioritize open collaboration over profit.
- Creates Legal and Social Pressure: Platforms that host significant amounts of licensed, non-commercial content may face pressure—both from the public and potentially from legal frameworks—to respect these licenses. This could encourage a shift away from purely ad-driven models.
- Supports Ethical Platforms: Licensing can inspire migration towards platforms that respect creator rights and provide transparent, non-exploitative services. As more creators license their work, demand for ethical alternatives to mainstream platforms could grow.
The Path Forward: Restoring Meritocracy Online
A collective movement towards content licensing could help restore the internet's meritocratic nature. When creators attach non-commercial licenses to their work, it becomes easier to distinguish between genuine, value-driven content and material produced for profit or by automated systems.
This movement is about supporting human-driven creativity. The internet was envisioned as a place where ideas compete based on their value—not their profitability. Content licensing is one tool that could help us move back towards that vision, rewarding creators for their genuine contributions.
Imagine a future where platforms must adapt to a growing volume of licensed, non-commercial content. Such a shift could fundamentally change how content is created, shared, and monetized, empowering creators and reducing exploitation.
Call to Action: Start Licensing Your Content Today
If you want to take control of your work and support an open, ethical internet, consider starting with a Creative Commons license:
- Choose Your License: Visit Creative Commons to pick a license that suits your needs. For non-commercial sharing, the Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike (CC-NC-SA) license is a strong choice.
- Add the License to Your Content: After selecting your license, apply it to your content. Include the license in descriptions or metadata, or add it to social media posts in your bio or a comment, such as: "Licensed under CC-NC-SA".
- Encourage Others: Spread the word about content licensing and its benefits. By raising awareness, we can collectively work towards a freer, more ethical internet.
Footnotes 1. Imperva Bad Bot Report 2023. Available at: Imperva Resource Library 2. Microsoft Earnings Release FY24 Q4. Available at: Microsoft.com 3. LinkedIn Post: Sanjay Dubey. Available at: LinkedIn 6. F5 Labs. “What Are Scrapers and Why Should You Care?”. Available at: F5 Labs